|
PROFITING
FROM CORPORATE DIVESTITURE An efficient market is characterized by
the inability to earn abnormal returns over the long run. The U. S.
capital markets are efficient enough that investment returns above those
dictated by the riskiness of the portfolio are very elusive. However,
hidden market inefficiencies do exist. Corporate Spin-Offs are one anomaly
that offers a "free-lunch" to improve portfolio returns. Spin-Offs often result
in a higher aggregate value for the constituent pieces. Many diversified
companies are electing to spin-off parts of their business, having found
that this form of divestiture leads to greater shareholder value. A
Spin-off is a tax-free transaction in which a parent corporation transfers
the business to be spun-off to a new subsidiary, and then pays a special
dividend to its shareholders consisting of the shares of the new
subsidiary. After a spin-off, the new firm is a separate publicly traded
company, with a shareholder base identical to that of the parent
corporation. The shareholders of the parent company receive the shares of
the subsidiary on a pro-rata basis, without paying any additional
consideration or incurring any tax liability. The foremost advantage
of a spin-off is that it is tax efficient. This is especially significant
in situations where the assets to be divested have a low cost basis but a
high market value. Generally when a company distributes assets, including
subsidiary stock, the company recognizes a gain as though it had sold such
assets for their fair market value, and the recipient shareholder
recognizes dividend income on the receipt of the distribution. However, a
spin-off that meets the requirements of Section 355 of the Internal
Revenue Code is tax-free to the parent corporation and the receiving
shareholders. Spin-offs often help
satis~ shareholder demands to unlock hidden value and improve market
performance. Institutional investors are increasingly pushing management
to increase shareholder value. Many academic studies confirm that
spin-offs on average have outperformed the general market (Standard &
Poor's 500) by a significant margin. In addition, the evidence suggests a
spin-off can improve the market performance of the parent company too. From the point of view of the spun-off
company, the spin-off can create an opportunity for improved operating
performance under a highly focused management team with equity-based
incentives. And, the spin-off can achieve a market valuation based on its
own attributes, unaffected by the businesses of its former parent. A
spin-off can offer opportunities for the parent and subsidiary company,
particularly in cases where the two businesses have disparate operations
or capital requirements. Spin-offs help management successfully
facilitate strategic objectives, such as refocusing on "core
competencies", or separating a leveraged capital intensive businesses
from high-growth divisions. Divestitures can remove conflicts of interest
between two companies that constrain growth. For example, AT&T
spun-off Lucent Technologies to enhance that divisions ability to sell
equipment to AT&T's competitors.
Similarly, a spin-off can separate regulated businesses from
unregulated businesses, thereby providing greater diversification
opportunities. Spin-offs have proven to be a
tax-efficient and effective way to divest a business. They have gone from
being a technique to eliminate poor performers to becoming a means of
unlocking value. A spin-off yields important benefits to the parent and
the subsidiary company that are not available in a typical sale
transaction. We believe 1999 will be another strong year for spin-off
activity. |